The power-moderator problem

In early 2010 Reddit erupted over 'Saydrah', a prominent moderator revealed to work for a content company while moderating communities her employer's material could appear in — an early reckoning over undisclosed conflicts of interest and power-user influence.

In 2012 Reddit banned the account SolInvictus — operated by Ian Miles Cheong — after the Daily Dot reported he used his moderator positions on some of Reddit's largest subreddits to push links from sites that paid him, including GlobalPost, which confirmed it had hired him as a paid 'social media consultant.'

In 2013 the founder and top moderator of r/atheism, 'skeen', was removed by other moderators citing his inactivity, opening the way for sweeping rule changes that split one of Reddit's largest communities.

Moderators of r/technology, then a Reddit default subreddit, were exposed in April 2014 for secretly using AutoModerator to delete any submission whose title contained ~50 banned keywords including 'NSA', 'Snowden', 'Bitcoin', and 'net neutrality'. Reddit removed the subreddit from its default list in response.

Robert Allam, known as GallowBoob, became one of Reddit's highest-karma users and a moderator of dozens of large subreddits, drawing accusations of mass self-promotion and karma farming before a viral 'power mod' list triggered harassment and his eventual withdrawal from the platform.

In January 2016 the founder of the roughly 100,000-subscriber r/Frisson sold full moderator control of the community for about $1,000 to the operator of a frisson-themed website, in plain violation of Reddit's rules against selling communities.

u/N8theGr8 became a recurring example of Reddit's 'power moderator' problem — a single volunteer who, by 2021, moderated dozens of communities containing millions of members and organized a cross-subreddit protest demanding Reddit act on COVID-19 misinformation.

The creator and top moderator of r/KotakuInAction abruptly set the 100,000-member community private and stripped its other moderators, only for Reddit administrators to reverse the takeover within roughly an hour and later remove him entirely.

A handful of 'power moderators' control a disproportionate share of Reddit's biggest communities. The long-running controversy over u/AwkwardTheTurtle became the emblem of the problem.

Moderators of the 6.9-million-member r/CryptoCurrency dumped roughly $150,000 worth of the community's MOON token minutes before Reddit publicly announced it was shutting down the program that gave the token value — and were removed for what users called blatant insider trading.

Reddit removed the top moderator of r/LiveStreamFail after he used the 4-million-member subreddit to promote 'Million Dollar Fan', a reality show advertising a suspiciously large prize that collapsed amid scam allegations — reviving fears that moderators sell community access.

Moderators of r/Bitcoin permanently banned 'Bitcoin Mechanic', a prominent Bitcoin Knots developer, for a two-sentence post noting on-chain signaling around the contentious BIP-110 — reviving long-running accusations that the subreddit censors protocol dissent.